Are Mormons Christians? Latest LDS Leadership The First Vision

Is Rome and Salt Lake City on the same page?

Is Rome and Salt Lake City on the same page?

Eric Johnson

They are saying the photograph is value a thousand words, and this picture of the Vatican is definitely double. Pope Francis of the Roman Catholic Church held that the first presidency of the LDS introduced the Christus statue in the Vatican in Rome, Italy, on Saturday, March 9, 2019. The meeting of the LDS leaders in Rome together with all the Twelve Apostles was the dedication of the new LDS temple in Rome, held on Sunday 10 . March 2019. [19659003] Seventeenth LDS president Russell M. Nelson, who works as a sort of "Pope" of 16 million members of the LDS Church – and Paul Francis met with greater than half an hour, once they mentioned social issues and the considerations of younger individuals in the church and the individuals's want worship God. Paul Francis, who is a liberal in each his political and spiritual views, has many opponents of the Church who don’t agree with their socialist agenda.

In response to the official newspaper of the LDS Church, Deseret News, Nelson gave the Pope a statue of Christ and a replica of "The Family: A Declaration to the World." the variations are actual and necessary, however they don’t seem to be as essential as we’ve got in widespread – our considerations about individuals's struggling, the significance of freedom of religion for society as an entire, and the significance of building bridges over the partitions of segregation

Deseret News article explains how these two churches have been in the debate over the final 5 many years. In reality, they’ve mixed their efforts in humanitarian efforts, similar to emergency and humanitarian assist, however "strive to defend freedom of religion and support the family". In parallel, we’ve got tasks with Catholic help providers round the world in over 43 nations. We’ve been partners on the shoulder and we try to alleviate the struggling by making an attempt to assist people who find themselves struggling. He was very all in favour of it and was very cordial, very type to us. ”

It is good leaders for leaders of various religions to be friendly. Nevertheless, if the impression is that two religions are alike, until the same, based mostly on their mixed efforts to charity, this is dangerous. Why did Nelson and LDS leaders present the statue of Jesus to the Pope and not the statue of Moroni? Definitely, this statue symbolizes the look that there’s a widespread belief between the two religions, however relating to the essential beliefs of Christianity, together with Jesus' view, there are lots of differences that can’t be reconciled. (To see the differences between LDS Jesus and Mormonism Jesus, click here.)

What about official LDS educating?

One not must level out the differences between Catholicism and Mormonism, slightly than pointing to an assumption which is supposed to be given by God to the LDS scriptures. Based on Joseph Smith's history, 1:19 in the nice bead – one in every of the 4 normal features of Mormonism – Joseph Smith asked God which church he ought to be a part of, and was advised that he should be a part of

none of them because they have been all improper; and the One who showed me stated that each one their religions have been horror in his eyes; that these professors have been all corrupt; that "they approach me with their lips, but their hearts are far from me, they teach the doctrines of the commandments of men who have the form of divinity, but they deny its power."

If God actually stated this have to be understood:

  • "All (not some) of their religions were horrified in his eyes." "They approach me with their lips, but their hearts are far from me."
  • They train the doctrines that folks have corrupted
  • They appear divine but deny the power of God.

. Then in verse 20 it stated that God "refused" Smith "to join one of them." Notice, it doesn’t say "join" with different church buildings, however "join one of them." If any verse exhibits that the leaders of Mormon shouldn’t be a part of arms with other religions, comparable to the Catholic, this seems to be it!

I feel this assertion in the current Church Guide is acceptable: "Many in the Christian world are sincere and their false doctrinal conclusions are not their own fault" (Previous Testament Scholar Handbook 1 Kings-Malachi Religion 302, 2003, p. 166). If non-Mormons who contemplate themselves "Christian" have "false doctrinal conclusions", JS-History 1:19 is just not emphasised throughout Mormonism in order not to remain as myths that each one sincere believers in God are

What Apostle Bruce R McConkie has stated about the Catholic Church?

At the starting of the article, President Nelson was quoted as saying: “The doctrines and disagreements are real and they are important, but they are not nearly as important as we have common things. . . “Although Nelson admits differences, he seems to want to minimize these differences by emphasizing“ similarities ”reminiscent of combined efforts to do social work by educating his members to do good. Nonetheless, the teachings of many earlier leaders in the LDS Church make it clear that the differences are solely lateral.

Contemplate one leader who criticizes Catholicism. In his main publication Mormon Doctrine, initially revealed in 1958, the Apostle Bruce R. McConkie contained a reference to "Catholicism" by taking the reader's "Look at the Church of the Devil" (p. 108). So the readers who have gone to this chapter would have read this in the first paragraph: males on a course that leads away from God and his regulation and thus salvation in the kingdom of God (p. 129).

Saying that faith, comparable to Catholicism, takes "men to the course leader") away from God "and thus" salvation in the kingdom of God "is a judgmental opinion. McConkie further stated that

is not any salvation outdoors this true Church, the Church of Jesus Christ. There’s one Christ, one church, one gospel, one plan of salvation, one set of salvation ordinances, one group of authorized individuals. . . . Subsequently, all churches or organizations that fulfill human pure beliefs and hold him coming to the truths of Christ and his gospel are subsequently not of God.

Although the subsequent 1966 version took the next half, the Unique Version continued: "Such agencies have been and have established or supported the devil who is the enemy of all righteousness."

McConkie then talked about the unique LDS scriptures and then referred to the Ebook of Mormon Nephi, who

saw that this church took away many covenants and many peculiar and helpful elements of the gospel of the sheep; that it distorted the proper methods of the Lord; that it has eliminated many teachings from the Bible; that it was the mother of the harlots; and, finally, the Lord returns the gospel of salvation. (1 Ne. 13: 24-42).

The subsequent paragraph was also taken from the 1966 version, the place McConkie went on:

Nephi continued to consider that this church was the "mother of abominations" and the "whore of the whole earth" who sat in lots of waters, and dominated the entire country, all nations , but amongst the households, languages, and peoples. ”As an alternative, the kingdoms of the true church have been small on earth (1 Ne. 14: 9-17; 2 Thess. 2: 1-12)

Who was the McConkie Reference? The 1958 model made it very clear: "Disputes and interference between the Catholic Church and the Communist forces could well lead to the fulfillment of this prediction." Catholicism, Protestantism and other "ism"):

  1. It will be referred to as by his identify
  2. It’s inbuilt his gospel
  3. Father appeared
  4. Not forged an eternal hearth, comparable to "a great and terrible church"

Was McConkie excessive on the view of the Catholic Church? The answer is not any. He felt that his description of the "Church of the Devil" was synonymous with Catholicism, a church that failed in the above-mentioned four-fold check

What about the views of other leaders?

Some might imagine perhaps McConkie stated he was his own. Though the current leaders are cautious in their political correctness, the 15th President Gordon B. Hinckley, the man whom most of the Latter-day Saints have been praised, made it very clear that he did not need to be a part of different spiritual perception methods. For instance, he wrote a church in 1976 that stated:

They [Mormons] are usually categorised as Protestants because they don’t seem to be Catholic. Truly, they don’t seem to be closer to Protestantism than Catholicism. They cannot be grouped either historically or on the basis of a contemporary affiliation, theology or apply. … Suffice it to say that its theology, group, and practices are, in many respects, utterly unique in at the moment's Christian religions (15th President Gordon B. Hinckley, Mormon? Non-packaged tract, 1976. In brackets and the ellipse

Hinckley emphasised the variations, not the similarities, and he did not supply the statue of Christ to different church buildings to be a false signal of his religion and the like. Hinckley referred to the first imaginative and prescient, as mentioned above, and defined,

Our Catholic buddies, our Protestant pals, give us a definition of divinity in Nicene Creed. the everlasting Father and His Son, Jesus Christ and it provides you and me an understanding of our relationship with them. Every of us is a toddler of God. God's son or daughter in a very real sense and we will pray to Him and He hears and solutions our prayers ("God's Nature," Church News, July 1, 2006, p. 2).

Hinckley admitted the differences in the faith of different religions with Jesus:

President Hinckley spoke of the testimony of Jesus Christ to those outdoors the Church who say Latter-day Saints "do not believe in traditional Christ". , I don’t. The normal Christ they converse shouldn’t be the Christ I converse. For Christ, of whom I converse, is revealed in this Occasions of Fulness of the Occasions. He and his Father appeared to his son Joseph Smith in 1820, and when Joseph left the day, he knew extra about the nature of God than all the discovered academics of the gospel of the time. The Gospel is on our head, Church News, June 20, 1998, p. 7.

In the Church we have now critics, lots of whom are. They say we do not consider in Christian Christianity. There is something they say ("We look at Christ," Ensign (conference publication), Might 2002, p. 90). Trinity:

If the acceptance of the Trinity doctrine makes Christ, then in fact Latter-day Saints are usually not Christians because they consider that the Trinity doctrine, expressed in trendy Protestant and Catholic theology, is Christian theology and Greek philosophy (A special Jesus? The Recollection of Saints Christ, p. it is introduced in the Encyclopedia of Mormon:

Latter-day Saints maintain that Christians are in the broadest sense those who base their beliefs on the teachings of Jesus and have a private relationship with him. In this definition, they recognize the understanding of Catholic, Japanese Orthodox, Protestant and Latter-day Saints on the grounds that Latter-day Saint Christianity is the restored fulness of the gospel of Christ (Encyclopedia of Mormonism 1: 271).

Word that the final statement could be very cautious: "… with understanding that Latter-day Saint Christianity is the restored fulness of the gospel of Christ." It’s, as many Latter-day Saints perceive, the only one with a prophet and apostles who have direct contact with God. Subsequently, Mormon leaders do not permit:

  • A person related to their church until this man is baptized into Mormonism, dominated by those with authority of the "priesthood", despite the fact that this individual would already have been baptized by way of an exterior "Christian" church
  • Any member of another church who strikes to the LDS temple or joins any temple ordinances
  • A non-member who teaches or performs a number one position in the Church.

In fact I wouldn't anticipate the LDS Church to permit any of this stuff. In any case, it’s a distinctive religion of its personal. To provide the Pope a character of Christ who appears to be making an attempt to make Mormonism and Catholicism, it seems the same, is each embarrassing and deceptive.

What other leaders have stated

What different public authorities have stated about the LDS Church, permit me to make a number of references to different leaders. (Notice: I think that Nelson talked about the references to the Pope a half-hour meeting each of those):

"Secondly, it’s common floor that if the Church of Christ has not continued, then the gate of hell should have prevailed towards him; and they refer us to this pampering music Matt. 16:18, which reads: – And I also say to you that you are Peter; and on this rock I’ll construct my church, and the gates of hell shall rule towards it. “They claim that if the Church has ceased to exist, the gates of hell have taken over her and the promise of Jesus must be forged. But we tell the Catholics that the Church of Christ has not ceased to exist, and Peter has not ceased to exist, but both the Church and Peter are in heaven, far from the gates of hell and far beyond the horrible soul-destroying layouts of popery. The gates of hell have taken over and continue to dominate the Catholic mothers and all of his Protestant daughters; but as in the apostolic Church of Christ, he rests in the mansion of eternal happiness, where he remains with the indomitable Catholic Church, with all his pope and bishop, and with all his dark daughters they are cast into hell; Then it is said: Rejoice in heaven, and ye holy apostles and prophets; for God hath given you upon him, and he shall hear the voice of the great people of heaven, saying, Alleluia: salvation, glory, honor, and power unto the LORD our God; for his righteousness is righteous and righteous, for he hath judged a great whore that broke the earth with her fornication, and she hath given her hand out of the blood of her servant in her hand. And again they say, "Alleluia" and his smoke rises forever and forever. And when the Catholics and Protestants hear all the heavens and all the holy apostles and prophets who rejoice in the fall of Babylon, they learn that the Church of Christ is still in heaven and that the gates of hell have not taken hold of him; then they learn where the apostolic and prophetic forces support; then they see the difference between the glory of the Church of Christ and the misery and misery of their own fiery temptations ”(Apostle Orson Pratt, Divine Fact of the Guide of Mormon, No. 3, p. 44).

"John predicts another great event that will happen immediately after the proclamation of the eternal gospel – namely after the great Babylon crash. When the first angel had completed his mission, he said, "And another angel adopted, saying, Babylon has fallen, fallen, a fantastic city, because he did all the nations drink the wrath of his anger." [Revelation 14:8.] The notifier has told us what Babylon means in the seventeenth chapter: it is represented in the name of a woman called "HIGHER SOUND AND COUNTY." In the first verse, this woman is represented as a "nice whore sitting in many waters." ; T the most horrible judgments that shortly come collectively and sweep over the nations through which he has energy, and finally are burned with hearth, for thus the Lord has spoken. God who keeps His fierce anger on them, and He won’t cease until He has made an ideal end, and until their names are mocked beneath heaven ”(Apostle Orson Pratt, Divine Authenticity Guide Mormon, No. 6, 84-85). Closures in their unique type.

“Christianity, as is known in the present world, is far from what could have been expected of it. It has not succeeded in creating the principles that Christ taught among the children of men. The great Catholic division of the Christian world, the Catholic Church, is a national responsibility for any country. It dominates the great power in the minds and hearts of the children of men, but it is rather bad than good. It brings countless thousands to regular recognition; it rarely brings one man into repentance and rejection of sins ”(Apostle Hyrum M. Smith, Convention Reviews, October 1916, 42).

“Here is the divine authority. Is there any such requirement for our friends or neighbors? We know the claim of the Catholic Church, and all we say in our answer is that "they know them of your fruit." These were the words of our Savior, and it is enough for this point. But our Protestant friends don't even have a big claim. They have the form of divinity but deny its power. And because they don't have the authority, they think no one else is ”(first president Charles W. Nibley, convention reviews, Oct. 1926, p. 24).

"The Protestant Reformation that resulted in numerous Christian religions – about 2 hundred and fifty of those that at the moment are in America are unproven evidence that an awesome apostasy occurred when the Grasp and the previous prophets had predicted it. Martin Luther, John Calvin, Wesley brothers and different protesters who opposed Catholicism did not demand divine restoration of the Holy Priesthood nor the rules and ordinances of the gospel ”(Seventy Milton R. Hunter, Conference Reviews), April 1946, 143.]

“Once upon a time I was sad to know that this church was not numbered among Protestant churches. But now I understand that the Church of Christ is more than a demonstration of the mistakes and evil of Catholicism. This Church was established in the only way in which the Church of Christ can be founded with the direct authority of God ”(Ninth President David O. McKay, Conference Stories, April 1927, p. 105).

”towards the Atonement of Jesus Christ. I converse it completely: No Catholic priest of the Pope understands the Atonement of Jesus Christ! In the event that they did, this terrible doctrine of the unique sin can be eliminated. Thus, the Atonement and its relationship with the human family is the next point that exhibits the renunciation of the Catholic Church ”(Joseph Fielding Smith, Answers to the Gospel Questions, three: 178-179).

”[Referring to Matthew 16:13-19] The talk amongst Catholics is extremely absurd. It’s value considering that the Lord will create his church for any man, regardless of how trustworthy and fantastic he may be. It’s the Church of Jesus Christ, not the Church of St. Peter ”(10th President Joseph Fielding Smith, Selection of Solutions to the Gospel Questions: Research Course for the Melchizedek Priesthood Quorum 1972-73, p. 188. Mine Mine). 19659003] Conclusion

From the first viewpoint, the phrases of leaders who converse of "politically erroneous" historical past and even lately to leaders, Mormonism has by no means thought-about Catholicism a religion that leads individuals to the heavenly kingdom. Perhaps the Pope doesn’t understand or even care about the great efforts of the LDS mission in the Catholic nations of Central and South America and the Philippines, and lots of of hundreds of Catholics have been transformed into beliefs. Becoming a member of arms with the leaders of the LDS faith might have many consequences, as I can imagine that LDS missionaries look to the coming Catholic translators of the Pope assembly with their leaders in Rome. So long as Mormonism holds the idea that it is a "restored" church with priesthood keys, Catholicism continues to be seen as the "folding" of true Christianity beneath the management of Mormon.